A Lutheran pastor was criticized recently by his church for participating in an inter-faith memorial service for school shooting victims in Connecticut. The challenge hinged on whether the service constituted “joint worship,” which the church prohibits as suggesting that all faiths are equally valid. Thus, the controversy touched on the central tension in a multi-faith world: can one adhere to an authentic faith tradition while living in community with others? Another Lutheran pastor in Brooklyn, David Benke, had a more defensible perspective:
The discomfort with joint-faith worship points to a larger issue and is not confined to Lutherans, and is something I often associate with more conservative evangelical groups. But it’s a misguided view in any case. The quoted doctrinal justification given in the Times article above was that interfaith activities violate the first commandment: “I am the Lord thy God.” And there is concern over radical relativism, one belief is as good as another. But that’s a tribalistic perspective and a good example of why mainline churches are losing ground in a global community where diversity is packed into every walk of life, including religion. More practical, realistic and defensible is Abraham Heschel’s more inclusive approach of “the tragic insufficiency of human faith,” which leads to the conclusion the “no religion is an island.” That should, in the face of the tragic mysteries of life, in no way undermine Lutheranism.